Public Interest SA Supports Treasury Intervention Amid Deepening Financial Crisis in the City of Johannesburg

Johannesburg, South Africa. Wednesday, 6 May 2026 — Public Interest SA notes with grave concern the contents of the Minister of Finance’s correspondence to the Executive Mayor of the City of Johannesburg regarding what appears to be widespread transgressions of the Municipal Finance Management Act (MFMA), the Municipal Standard Chart of Accounts (mSCOA) regulatory framework, and broader constitutional financial governance obligations.

The picture painted by National Treasury is deeply alarming and points to a municipality facing potentially catastrophic fiscal instability, deteriorating governance controls, severe liquidity distress, and the implementation of what Treasury itself describes as an unfunded adjustments budget.

The allegations contained in the Minister’s letter are not merely technical or administrative in nature. They strike at the heart of lawful public financial management and the constitutional duty imposed on public officials to safeguard public resources prudently, transparently, and sustainably.

Of particular concern are allegations that:

• the City approved an unfunded budget based on overstated revenue projections and understated expenditure;

• the municipality faces escalating unauthorised expenditure;

• creditors have ballooned to approximately R25.2 billion while cash reserves remain critically inadequate;

• financial reporting systems remain materially non-compliant with mSCOA requirements;

• financial data integrity may be compromised by fragmented and unreliable systems; and

• the City entered into substantial salary obligations despite apparent fiscal incapacity to sustain them.

Public Interest SA supports the Minister’s firm intervention and believes that Treasury’s “tough love” approach is both necessary and justified under the present circumstances. The failure to intervene decisively where persistent material breaches of financial management obligations exist would itself amount to a dereliction of constitutional oversight responsibilities.

The implementation of unfunded budgets is not a harmless political exercise. It exposes municipalities to operational collapse, undermines service delivery, jeopardises infrastructure maintenance, weakens investor confidence, harms suppliers and small businesses dependent on municipal payments, and ultimately shifts the burden of maladministration onto residents.

Critically, public officials and accounting authorities must appreciate that financial misconduct within organs of state may attract not only administrative consequences, but also potential civil and criminal liability.

While municipalities are governed primarily by the MFMA rather than the PFMA, the underlying legal principles are analogous and clear: accounting officers and officials entrusted with public finances may not knowingly authorise unlawful, irregular, unfunded, or reckless financial commitments in contravention of governing legislation.

Sections of the MFMA expressly criminalise certain forms of financial misconduct, including failures by accounting officers and senior officials to comply with statutory obligations relating to unauthorised, irregular, fruitless and wasteful expenditure. Where decisions are taken in conscious disregard of legal financial constraints, the risk of personal accountability and possible criminal investigation cannot be discounted.

Public Interest SA therefore calls for:

• the immediate publication of a comprehensive remedial action plan by the City;

• full transparency regarding the City’s actual liquidity position and unfunded obligations;

• urgent oversight by the Gauteng Provincial Government and relevant legislative committees;

• an independent review of the salary agreement and its fiscal sustainability;

• strengthened protection for officials and whistleblowers who disclose financial misconduct; and

• accountability for any individuals found to have acted unlawfully or recklessly in the management of public finances.

Johannesburg occupies a uniquely important position within South Africa’s economic architecture. Its fiscal instability carries implications not only for residents of the City, but for the broader provincial and national economy.

The situation requires urgency, honesty, competence, and lawful governance — not political expediency.

END

Issued by: Public Interest SA