MEDIA STATEMENT
Public Interest SA Statement on Recent Criticism of KwaZulu-Natal Police Operations
For Immediate Release
August 3, 2024
Public Interest SA has noted with concern the recent wave of criticism directed at the KwaZulu-Natal police following the increase in fatalities among suspected criminals during police operations. While we unequivocally abhor any use of excessive force by law enforcement, we stand by our officers who operate under extreme conditions to protect our communities from violent criminals.
Lieutenant-General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi, KwaZulu-Natal's police commissioner, highlighted the perilous nature of policing in a province plagued by high levels of violence and murder. The recent operations that resulted in the deaths of several suspects are a direct consequence of the aggressive criminal elements police officers face daily. These suspects, armed with deadly weapons, pose a severe threat not only to law enforcement but also to the broader community.
It is disheartening to hear calls for an independent inquiry into police conduct without a full appreciation of the context in which these officers operate. Critics have argued that these operations, often conducted at night or in the early hours of the morning, lack transparency. However, such timings are strategic, aimed at isolating suspects from the public and minimising collateral damage.
Public Interest SA does not support the call for a commission of inquiry. Instead, we urge the Independent Police Investigative Directorate (IPID) to intensify its oversight and swiftly investigate any reported instances of police misconduct followed by concomitant consequence management where wrongdoing is unearthed. We believe that a commission of inquiry would, not only, inadvertently expose police methods, potentially aiding criminals in evading justice but a waste of state resources.
Chairperson of Public Interest SA, Tebogo Khaas, stated, "To suggest that police do not exercise caution when using deadly force against murderous criminals who terrorise communities is irresponsible. Expecting officers to face heavily armed criminals with non-lethal means is both impractical and dangerous."
The bravery and dedication of our law enforcement officers in KwaZulu-Natal deserve our support and recognition. These men and women often engage dangerous criminals, including izinkabi (hired assassins), under life-threatening conditions. It is crucial to remember the numerous instances where police have successfully apprehended suspects without resorting to gunfire.
“Let us not forget that the police are often engaged in asymmetric battles against ruthless criminals who will not hesitate to kill law enforcement officers or anyone who attempts to stop them. KwaZulu-Natal remains a hotspot for violent crime, and our police are constitutionally empowered to use necessary force to uphold the law and protect the public. We call on the community and all stakeholders to unite in support of our police officers, who risk their lives daily to make South Africa a safer place,” added Khaas.
Public Interest SA stands firmly with the KwaZulu-Natal police and supports their efforts in combating crime. We encourage them to continue their judicious and courageous work in the face of daunting challenges.
END